Agency Financial Reports (AFR)
The Department of Health and Human Services' annual Agency Financial Report (AFR) provides fiscal and high-level performance results that enable the President, Congress, and American people to assess HHS’ accomplishments for each fiscal year (October 1 through September 30). This report provides an overview of HHS programs, accomplishments, challenges, and management's accountability for the resources entrusted to us. The report is prepared in accordance with the requirements of Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Circular A-136, Financial Reporting Requirements. PARIS contributes to the AFR’s Payment Integrity Report by providing a high-level overview of the benefits the program has brought, including with examples provided by State public assistance agencies of the ways they have realize cost savings with PARIS.
Link: Agency Financial Reports (AFR) - PARIS found on page 221
Cost Benefit Analysis (CBA) Reports
The initial 2008 Cost Benefit evaluation focused on how well each of the States were able to develop and implement PARIS. Organizational placement issues, communications between participating programs and those responsible for implementation, assessments of startup barriers, and the adequacy of policies and procedures for accomplishing project objectives were included in the assessment. The outcome evaluation was directed at identifying the extent to which States can effectively use PARIS data to accomplish their goals, at examining the costs and benefits of participation in PARIS, and identifying those factors that are associated with maximizing the benefits relative to costs.
- PARIS Cost-Benefit Analysis - Executive Summary December 2008 (PDF)
- PARIS Cost-Benefit Analysis - Final Report December 2008 (PDF)
PARIS Evaluation Project
The PARIS Evaluation Project Report sample includes States that have participated in PARIS for several years, some that have participated for only a few years, and, with the inclusion of the grantees, some brand new States.
The U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) Reports
About the GAO Report
Public assistance programs make millions of dollars in improper payments every year. Some of these improper payments occur because state and local agencies that administer the programs lack adequate, timely information to determine recipients' eligibility for assistance. This inability to share information can result in both federal and state tax dollars being needlessly spent on benefits for the same individuals and families in more than one state. In 1997, staff at the Administration for Children and Families (ACF) within the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) began a project to help states share eligibility information with one another. The public assistance reporting information system (PARIS) interstate match helps states share information on public assistance programs, such as Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) and Food Stamps, to identify individuals or families who may be receiving benefit payments in more than one state simultaneously. Officials in almost all of the 16 states and the District of Columbia that participated in PARIS reported that the project has helped identify improper TANF, Medicaid, or Food Stamp payments in more than one state. Despite its successes, the project also has several limitations. First, the opportunity to detect improper duplicate payments is not as great as it could be because only one-third of the states participate in the project. Second, participating states do not have adequate protocols or guidelines to facilitate critical interstate communication. As a result, some states have reported problems that compromise the effectiveness of the project, such as difficulty determining whether an individual identified in a match is actually receiving benefits in another state. Third, state administrators for the TANF, Medicaid, and Food Stamp programs have not always placed adequate priority on using PARIS matches to identify recipients who are residing in other states. As a result, individuals may continue to receive or have benefits paid on their behalf in more than one state even after they were identified through the matching process. Finally, because the PARIS match is only designed to identify people after they are already on the rolls, it does not enable the states to prevent improper payments from being made in the first place.
About the GAO
The U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) is an agency that works for Congress and the American people. Congress asks GAO to study the programs and expenditures of the federal government. GAO, commonly called the investigative arm of Congress or the congressional watchdog, is independent and nonpartisan. It studies how the federal government spends taxpayer dollars. GAO advises Congress and the heads of executive agencies (such as Environmental Protection Agency, EPA, Department of Defense, DOD, and Health and Human Services, HHS) about ways to make government more effective and responsive. GAO evaluates federal programs, audits federal expenditures, and issues legal opinions. When GAO reports its findings to Congress, it recommends actions. Its work leads to laws and acts that improve government operations, and save billions of dollars.
GAO reports: https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-01-935